the left overall in the USA is completely busted-yet-still-functioning, almost without exception.
people (organizers/planners in particular) keep doing the exact same things over and over again, even when they’re broken, or detrimental.
there’s just enough of a positive sentiment around outcomes overall that people think “it’s working”.
it’s not, it just feels like it, sometimes.
a functional definition of “working” has to include getting past where we’ve been for years, if not decades, in a positive – and advancing – direction.
as it stands, we’re stuck with the same approaches, with ever-lessening progress.
to make things worse, things are busted in a variety of ways, and people’s levels of access and power vary, both institutionally and individually.
so we argue, constantly and call it praxis or transformation or whatever.
it’s not, it’s just more of the same.
all of which is made worse by most people not just being flat-out-right or flat-out-wrong, just mostly right, give or take, about what they know best.
or even worse, cape on behalf of oppressed people, with no idea of direction, goals or even if said caping is making things better or worse.
then we argue about the caping.
just as its been for decades, just faster and more intense.
i do have hope, just not when people keep on repeating themselves.
which everybody does, but not always in the same way.
mobilizing and organizing aren’t the same.
i think we’re stuck, in general, at not building the sorts of movements that could lead to at least understanding the differences between mobilizing and organizing.
h/t: @er0tikka, @lavlobster, black agenda report, and as always, my twitter timeline